SPACE FRONTIER
Lehigh Valley
Space Frontier

May 11, 2020

The Public Voice on the
Cutting Edge of the
Future

































NATIONAL SPACE SOCIETY

NSS Position Paper: The Artemis Moon Program
by National Space Society













The NASA Artemis Moon program aims to land the first woman and the next man on the Moon
by 2024, a goal that the National Space Society (NSS) applauds. Due to on-going efforts to
cancel or reduce some of the best aspects of Artemis, NSS has decided to specifically endorse
the following:

Human Lunar Lander Commercial Contracting

NSS strongly endorses NASA contracting the service of landing on the Moon, rather than
building, owning, and operating a lunar landing system itself.

NSS endorses NASA’s recent selection of three technologically dissimilar vendors, Dynetics,
SpaceX, and the Blue Origin “National Team” for the initial contracts to provide human class
lunar landers. Although only one vendor can be selected to support the initial return of humans
to the lunar surface, NSS urges the development of preferably all three, and definitely at least
two of the vendors’ proposals to operational status to ensure that NASA can reliably reach the
lunar surface in a sustainable fashion.

NSS endorses the use of commercially procured launch vehicles to send lunar lander
components to the Moon.

While it may in the short term seem burdensome to U.S. taxpayers to fund three human
landers versus a single government owned vehicle, longer term such a strategy will lead to
more diverse capabilities, higher total resiliency, and lower program risk and indeed cost to
taxpayers. Instead of funding a government-owned vehicle like the Shuttle that has a finite
program life and no market checks on cost, this procurement strategy will create a new
sustainable commercial space sector that will over time compete and innovate to bring new
capabilities to the market at ever lower price points.

Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS)

NSS strongly endorses NASA’s Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) program with its
emphasis on multiple commercially procured lunar landers and a willingness on the part of
NASA to assume greater risk than is normally the case with NASA programs. CLPS is literally
NASA done right and provides a shining example for other NASA programs to follow.

NSS is pleased to note the selection of Astrobotic and Intuitive Machines in the smaller class of
CLPS lunar landers and looks forward to their initial lunar landings in 2021.

NSS applauds the recent additions of Blue Origin, Ceres Robotics, Sierra Nevada Corporation,
SpaceX, and Tyvak to the pool of vendors eligible to bid on proposals to provide deliveries to
the surface of the Moon through NASA’s CLPS initiative. These additions increase the list of
CLPS participants on contract to 14.

NSS supports the addition of the Masten medium-class XL-1 lander to the CLPS program and
looks forward to many successful landings in the area of the lunar south pole.

Role of the Gateway

NSS endorses the flexibility NASA has shown in not requiring that a lunar lander dock with the
Gateway.

NSS supports the use of commercially procured launch vehicles to resupply the Gateway and
is pleased to note that NASA has selected SpaceX’s Dragon XL as the initial logistics vehicle
to supply the Gateway. NSS urges that a second technologically dissimilar commercial
provider be selected to help ensure reliable service to the Gateway.

Sustainable Lunar Economy

NSS supports the efforts of NASA to create an economically sustainable lunar landing program
and cautions against any approach to Artemis that is not targeted toward future commercial
operations on and around the Moon. It is essential the ISRU (In-Situ Resource Utilization) be a
core part of Artemis.

NSS endorses the focus on exploring the potential water resources of the lunar poles.
NSS strongly endorses NASA’s Volatiles Investigating Polar Exploration Rover (VIPER), a
mobile robot that will roam around the Moon’s south pole looking for water ice. The VIPER
mission will provide surface-level detail of where the water is and how much is available for
use.

Tipping Point Grants

NSS also endorses “Tipping Point” grants[i] in general and calls attention to the following
Moon-related actions by NASA:

An unfunded Space Act Agreement with SpaceX to study the impact of landing large vehicles
on the Moon. An additional Space Act Agreement with SpaceX calls for the study of on-orbit
Starship-based fuel transfer.

Three unfunded Space Act Agreements with Blue Origin related to the development of lunar
lander technologies.

A $3M Tipping Point grant to SpaceX to study methods of on-orbit ship-to-ship fuel transfer
A $10M Tipping Point grant going to Blue Origin to conduct a ground-based demonstration of
hydrogen and oxygen liquification and storage.

NSS looks forward to these and other Tipping Point grants becoming the core of a program of
lunar exploration and development that leads eventually to lunar bases and finally settlements,
rather than another unsustainable “flags-and-footprints” Apollo-like program. NSS believes that
the costs of establishing and maintaining a lunar base will be paid back many-fold in lowering
the amount of new technology needed to be developed to go to Mars.

[i] The public-private partnerships established through Tipping Point selections combine NASA
resources with an industry contribution of at least 25% of the program costs, shepherding the
development of critical space technologies while also saving the agency, and American
taxpayers, money. See https://www.nasa.
gov/directorates/spacetech/solicitations/tipping_points.



Artist's concept of the Space Launch System rocket and Orion capsule prepared for launch.
Credits: NASA

What is Artemis?

NASA is committed to landing American astronauts, including the first woman and the next
man, on the Moon by 2024. Through the agency’s Artemis lunar exploration program, we will
use innovative new technologies and systems to explore more of the Moon than ever before.
We will collaborate with our commercial and international partners to establish sustainable
missions by 2028. And then we will use what we learn on and around the Moon to take the
next giant leap – sending astronauts to Mars.

Why Go to the Moon?
With the Artemis program we will:

Demonstrate new technologies, capabilities, and business approaches needed for future
exploration including Mars

Establish American leadership and a strategic presence on the Moon while expanding our U.S.
global economic impact

Broaden our commercial and international partnerships

Inspire a new generation and encourage careers in STEM


How Do We Get There?

NASA’s powerful new rocket, the Space Launch System (SLS), will send astronauts aboard
the Orion spacecraft nearly a quarter million miles from Earth to lunar orbit. Astronauts will
dock Orion at the Gateway and transfer to a human landing system for expeditions to the
surface of the Moon. They will return to the orbital outpost to board Orion again before
returning safely to Earth.

When Will We Get There?

Ahead of the human return, we will send a suite of science instruments and technology
demonstrations to the lunar surface through commercial Moon deliveries beginning in 2021.


The agency will fly two missions around the Moon to test its deep space exploration systems.
NASA is working toward launching Artemis I, an uncrewed flight to test the SLS and Orion
spacecraft together, followed by the Artemis II mission, the first SLS and Orion test flight with
crew. NASA will land astronauts on the Moon by 2024 on the Artemis III mission and about
once a year thereafter.

Download the Artemis Fact Sheet

What Will We Do There?

While Mars remains our horizon goal, we have set our sights first on exploring the entire
surface of the Moon with human and robotic explorers. We will send astronauts to new
locations, starting with the lunar South Pole. At the Moon, we will:

Find and use water and other critical resources needed for long-term exploration

Investigate the Moon’s mysteries and learn more about our home planet and the universe

Learn how to live and operate on the surface of another celestial body where astronauts are
just three days from home

Prove the technologies we need before sending astronauts on missions to Mars, which can
take up to three years roundtrip


Going forward to the Moon will be the shining moment of our generation. This moment will
belong to you – the Artemis Generation. Are you ready?vcccNASA is committed to landing
American astronauts, including the first woman and the next man, on the Moon by 2024.
Through the agency’s Artemis lunar exploration program, we will use innovative new
technologies and systems to explore more of the Moon than ever before. We will collaborate
with our commercial and international partners to establish sustainable missions by 2028. And
then we will use what we learn on and around the Moon to take the next giant leap – sending
astronauts to Mars.


Why Go to the Moon?
With the Artemis program we will:
Demonstrate new technologies, capabilities, and business approaches needed for future
exploration including Mars
Establish American leadership and a strategic presence on the Moon while expanding our U.S.
global economic impact
Broaden our commercial and international partnerships
Inspire a new generation and encourage careers in STEM


How Do We Get There?
NASA’s powerful new rocket, the Space Launch System (SLS), will send astronauts aboard
the Orion spacecraft nearly a quarter million miles from Earth to lunar orbit. Astronauts will
dock Orion at the Gateway and transfer to a human landing system for expeditions to the
surface of the Moon. They will return to the orbital outpost to board Orion again before
returning safely to Earth.

When Will We Get There?
Ahead of the human return, we will send a suite of science instruments and technology
demonstrations to the lunar surface through commercial Moon deliveries beginning in 2021.


The agency will fly two missions around the Moon to test its deep space exploration systems.
NASA is working toward launching Artemis I, an uncrewed flight to test the SLS and Orion
spacecraft together, followed by the Artemis II mission, the first SLS and Orion test flight with
crew. NASA will land astronauts on the Moon by 2024 on the Artemis III mission and about
once a year thereafter.
Apollo is the god of archery and the invention of
archery is credited to him and his sister Artemis. He has
a golden bow and arrows. As the god of Mousike (art of
Muses), Apollo presides over all music, songs, dance
and poetry. He is the inventor of string-music, and the
frequent companion of the Muse

Artemis as indicated above was the twin sister of Apollo
and goddess of the Moon in Greek mythology.

Whereas Apollo signified our former path to the Moon.
Now Artemis personifies our path to the Moon as the
name of NASA's program to return astronauts to the
lunar surface by 2024, including the first woman and
the next man. When they land, our American
astronauts will step foot where no human has ever
been before: the Moon’s South Pole.
The Crew of Apollo 11 - the 1st Manned  
American and World landing mission to
the Moon , (Left to Right)

Neil  A . Armstrong  ---  1st man on the
Moon and Commander of the mission

Michael Collins - The Command Module
Pilot  ... While Armstrong and Aldren were
on the Moon he remained behind in the
Columbia Command Module and orbited
the Moon.. At times he was out of touch
with all human beings when his orbit took
him to the dark side of the Moon ...

Buzz Aldren -- 2nd Man on the Moon and
the Lunar Module Pilot ... The LEM he
flew was called the Eagle....

Landing occurred at Tranquility base in
the Sea of Tranquility.

With NASA astronaut Neil Armstrong
uttereing these first words or thoughts
when he set foot on the moon at 02.56
GMT on July 21 1969.

'That's one small step for man, one giant
leap for mankind,'

Aldren saying as the 2nd man on the
Moon saying: “Beautiful view. Magnificent
desolation.” Then too as a Presbyterian,
Aldrin decided to hold a religious
ceremony on the Moon, and became the
first man to do so.
The Crew of Apollo 17 - the last Manned  
American and World landing mission to
the Moon ... Left Moon (Right to Left)

Eugene A. Cernan - 11th Person on the
Moon ans  Commander of the Mission and
last Earthling to walk on the Moon.

Ronald Evans - The Command Module
Pilot  ... While Cernan and Schmidt were
on the Moon he remained behind in the
Command Module called America and
orbited the Moon.. At times he was out of
touch with all human beings when his orbit
took him to the dark side of the Moon ...

Harrison Schmidtt -- 12nd Man on the
Moon and the Lunar Module Pilot ... The
LEM he flew was called the Challenger....

Landing occurred at the Taurus-Littrow
Valley , the astronauts during their stay on
the Moon took 3 EVA's and ,took lunar
samples, and deployed scientific
instruments.

Also with them was a biological
experiment containing five mice.

On December 14 at 5:54:37 p.m. EST,
The Atlantic noted that  humans left the
moon for what would turn out to be the
last time. But how did the three men who
made that departure -- taking their last
small steps, their last great leaps from the
lunar surface -- mark that occasion? What
parting words did they leave to the moon,
and to their fellow humans, and to history?

As reported by Miles O'Brien  in his tribute
to the bittersweet anniversary, the
commander of the Apollo 17 mission,
Gene Cernan, had prepared a speech to
mark his crew's lunar departure. It was
was appropriately lengthy and lofty.

He delivered it like this:

As I take man's last step from the surface,
back home for some time to come (but we
believe not too long into the future), I'd like
to just say what I believe history will
record: That America's challenge of today
has forged man's destiny of tomorrow.
And, as we leave the Moon at
Taurus-Littrow, we leave as we came and,
God willing, as we shall return: with peace
and hope for all mankind.

But The Atlantic notes that these words  
were not, technically, the last words ever
spoken on the moon. Cernan and his
crew, on the contrary, maintained a
decidedly less-epic dialogue as they did
the delicate work of lifting their little
spaceship off the lunar surface -- dialogue
that was mostly pragmatic and
mission-moderated, but dialogue that was
also, occasionally, the casual
conversation of guys who are having an
adventure together.

So then. What were the last -- really the
last -- words?

According to Apollo 7 astronaut Walter
Cunningham in his book The All-American
Boys, Cernan's final words on the moon
were: "Let's get this mother out of here."
(Or as O'Brien spells it, awesomely, "let's
get this mutha.") And there would be,
indeed, something wonderfully poetic
about "let's get this mother" -- excuse me,
mutha -- "outta here" as our parting words
to the moon: something very human and
honest and inscribed in its time.
On the 50th anniversary of the launch of the Saturn 5 rocket taking the crew of
Apollo 11 to the Moon - Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldren and Mike Collins to the Moon, I
was interviewed by Boston's Channel 25 at the John F Kennedy Presidential Library
and Museum concerning my thoughts concerning observing of the history making
event that day and what are my thoughts concerning man's place in space.

I replied by saying that I was caught up in the excitement of the original launch and
its successful Moon Landing and was thrilled to observe that anniversary at
Kennedy's Presidential Library ….Historically, Kennedy gave marching orders to
NASA to develop a Space Program which would take us to the Moon and
successfully come back within a decade … And as it happened, NASA  the
government agency created by Dwight Eisenhower successfully did this.

Unfortunately, for many years America back stepped from going to the Moon in
order to concentrate solely on Low Earth Orbit and other scientific missions … But
now we have new orders to go back to the Moon within 5 years … And hopefully,
this too would happen, even if via national election there is a change in the President
with different political ideas.

I have met Buzz Aldren, the 2nd Man on the Moon … I have met Eugene Cernan,
the last Man on the Moon … One is still alive , the other is dead, but both of them
want us to get back to the Moon safely as soon as possible. And Cernan, especially
doesn't want to go down in history as the last American, yet alone the last earthling
to go to the Moon.

They went on a program that evolved from Mercury, to Gemini and then to Apollo …
From information I received at a conference in Arlington, VA last June 2019, the next
Program to the Moon may be nicknamed Artemis and if that nickname be verified
since Artemis is the twin sister of Apollo that would indicate that woman will be
included in the crew that will be part of our future Moon landings and maybe, a
woman would be among the first crew members that will once again place human
foot prints on the regolith of the Moon.

In Apollo, NASA had help from the German rocket engineers that came to our soil
as result of our victory in WW II, and also from the Canadians and other nations that
provided us with needed engineers in the aerospace fields due to the shortage of
American talent produced by the Universities …President Kennedy specifically
asked Canadian Prime Minister to encourage his engineers to come to the States to
help us … Prime Minister Pearson complied by ending his nation's costly
commitment in developing a supersonic airplane; and this freed many highly skilled
and experiences engineers to come.

So as it will happen, when we go again, we will again ask the help of other nations
and welcome their involvement. But hopefully, our universities have done their job in
training the American talent needed to bring forth and carry on this awesome
endeavor in advancing the spacefaring civilization that will spring forth from the
fulfillment of mankind's past dreamss
Buzz Aldren in a picture
taken by Dennis Pearson
during NSS  ISDC speech
at San Diego in 2013
Eugene Cernan and Dennis
Pearson taken by former
Astronaut Tom Stafford
aduring free time at the
NSS ISDC at Los Angeles
in 2014

Space Shuttle Endeavour
docked to the ISS for the
last time. Endeavour flew
its final mission, STS-134,
to the International Space
Station (ISS) in May 2011.
After the conclusion of
STS-134, Endeavour was
formally decommissioned.
Arranged by Joe Bland  of the
Sacremento L5 in April 2020  in his
capacity as Chair of the National Space
Society;s Chapter Assembly .. Lynn
Zeilinski of the NSS assisted him n
arranging for the Lowell interview
Congratulation on Bennett Rutlege of the National Space Society's
Denver Chapter on his election to the Chair of the National Soace
Society's Chapter Assembly , He succeeds Joe Bland of the
Sacremento L5 Society ... Joe did an excellent job using social media
to address Chapter and Society issues and working within the new
Assembly Charter and bylaws, ... His Breakfast on the Moon
commemoration events for Apollo 11, Apollo 12 , Apollo 13 , Hubble ,
etc. were excellently done ... Joe Bland succeeded me as
Chairperson of the Chapter Assembly a position I held for 4  years
with an additional two year extension ... My administration transferred
the Chapter Assembly from a mostly Conference gathering to a
monthly gathering via social media and did much work to establish a
new Charter for the group as well as leave a draft bylaws for further
Chapter action ... I note that Chistine Nobbe of the St. Louis Space
frontier also needs to credited for her work on working on  a new
Charter. It is said about my stewardship as Chair is that I kept the CA
alive and set the groundwork for its revival.... Joe Bland was the
proper man to make what we established work ... So, Let Rutlege be
the man to make it flourish.... Please note - NSS Board Members
David Sturat of NSS Seattle and Larry Ahearn of Chicago closely
collaborated with the Chapter Assembly via the NSS Chapters
Committee of the Board of Directors which they were assigned to run
by the Board.